The Guardian gives HBP three out of five stars 
Andrew Pulver of The Guardian has posted an early review of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. Pulver gave the film three out of five stars, and here's why:
Putatively winsome all this may be, but what it actually does is throw the series' biggest weakness into sharp relief: film-making can (and does) control pretty much everything – except how the cute juvenile leads grow up. Still, director David Yates knows how to play all the cards. Although a touch ungainly, his film is solidly constructed, with lots of fine effects. If, as Potter approaches his final confrontation with Voldemort, the wizardly battles begin to resemble Lord of the Rings, it's hardly a handicap; this is tried and tested cinematic language, and does all it needs.
How do I include an avatar graphic?
Please note: The comments page is designed for commenting on the above item. Any off-topic commenting will be deleted. No links or HTML are allowed. To prevent spamming, your first comment will be manually approved by a Harry Potter Fan Zone staff member before it appears on this page. All comments made after that will appear automatically. Your first comment is classified as the first comment you make on Harry Potter Fan Zone, not your first comment on this item.
Click here for an RSS feed of this comments page.
© 2003 - 2010 Harry Potter Fan Zone (HPFZ)
Harry Potter Fan Zone is in no way affiliated with the copyright owners of Harry Potter, including J.K. Rowling, Warner Bros., Bloomsbury and Scholastic. Everything on the site is unofficial and original work.
